Every time i think ich understand accusative, ich find something that pokes holes in my understanding.

Most recently, i’ve operated on ns understanding that any time you have two unique entities (e.g., in Ich verfügen über einen Bruder) one von them should be accusation (in this case, Bruder which we see an the -en addition to the indefinite article).

Du schaust: Er ist kleiner als ich

This does not apply to Er war kleiner zusammen ich, though, and I’m notfall sure why?

I wrote ns “incorrect” version in an edit (Er zu sein kleiner als mich), und someone an extremely reputable corrected it together ich.

grammar accusative comparison
boost this question
edited Dec 17 "15 at 11:21

19.3k22 gold badges4646 silver badges7676 bronze badges
inquiry Dec 16 "15 at 20:15

rob brownrob brown
35122 silver badges77 kupfer badges
include a comment |

2 answers 2

energetic earliest Votes
The idea that anytime there are two unique entities, one des them should be accusative, ist wrong.

In general, it"s die verb the determines die cases ("the verb governs ns sentence"). Zum example, "haben" requires bei accusative object. That"s why you never learn einzel verbs, but always complete expressions ("etwas/jemanden (Akk) haben").

Occasionally, there are also verbs that require two accusation objects ("jemanden (Akk) etwas (Akk) nennen"). And for die verb "sein", both the subject und the Prädikatsnomen are bei the nominative ("Ich (Nom) bin befinde Bruder (Nom)").

Now zum a comparison making use of "als", ns things or persons that are contrasted are always bei the very same case. I beg your pardon cases to use depends again on the verb:

Er (Nom) zu sein kleiner zusammen ich (Nom)

Ich gebe lieber er (Dat) als ihr (Dat) ns Geschenk.

Mehr sehen: Durchschnittliche Bh Größe Mit 13 ? Durchschnittliche Körbchengröße Weltweit

Ich geliebt ihn (Akk) mehr als sie (Akk).

enhance this price
edited Jun 17 "20 at 8:52

reply Dec 16 "15 at 20:34

6,93622 gold badges1414 silver- badges2626 kupfer badges
add a comment |
The role of kleiner als zu sein comparison. It just works correctly wie man both cases are equal. Sie sort des write a bracket around the packet

<1st. Noun + wie + verklappt + 2nd. Noun>

and instert it in the sentence, according to die case that needs.

But they don"t need kommen sie be both nominative, as an

<Er zu sein kleiner zusammen ich>.

They could be deshalb both accusation (if applies)

Sie finden <ihn kleiner zusammen mich>.

In both example sentences the zuerst noun ist er, und the second ich. And the pieces bei brackets are von the form described above.

enhance this answer
edited Dec 17 "15 hinweisen 13:11
answer Dec 17 "15 at 12:59

30.2k1414 gelb badges9797 silver- badges210210 bronze- badges
include a comment |

her Answer

Thanks zum contributing in answer to Language stack Exchange!

Please it is in sure zu answer ns question. Carry out details and share her research!

But avoid

Asking weil das help, clarification, or responding to other answers.Making statements based upon opinion; rückseitig them hoch with references or mitarbeiter experience.

To find out more, lakers our tips on writing an excellent answers.

Mehr sehen: Warnung Fett Weg Spritze Cellulite Vorher Nachher, Hilfe Bei Cellulite: Fettweg

Draft saved
Draft discarded

Sign trost or log in in

Sign trost using google
Sign nach oben using facebook
Sign hoch using Email und Password

Post as a guest

emails Required, however never shown

Post together a guest


Required, but never shown

post Your price Discard

über clicking “Post her Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy und cookie policy

Not ns answer you're looking for? Browse various other questions tagged grammar accusative comparison or ask your own question.

Featured ~ above Meta
Why zu sein it "mir ist übel" and not "ich bin übel"?
Meaning und construction des "Ich bedanke mich"
Why isn't accusative used in the sentence "Wann macht ns Supermarkt auf?"
Why ns “dass” wie comparing statements with “als dass”?
"Ich weiß nicht, wann der Zug abfährt" — Why zu sein "der Zug" not accusative?
Why "die schlimmsten" and not "am schlimmsten"?
ich lerne fleißig Deutsch, zum mein chef zufrieden ist. Why not meinen?
Why is this not an the accusative/dative case?
warm Network inquiries more hot concerns

question feed
subscribe to rys
question feed to subscribe kommen sie this rys feed, copy and paste this URL right into your rss reader. Language
Stack austausch Network
site entwurf / logo © 2021 Stack exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Rev2021.11.10.40705 Language Stack exchange works best with JavaScript allowed

your privacy

von clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree stack Exchange kann sein store kekse on your device and disclose information an accordance with our Cookie Policy.